Free Standard Shipping on Web Orders over $75 (Lower 48 States only)

Good's Store Schaefferstown

Good's Store in Schaefferstown PA

Good's Store

2499 Stiegel Pike (Route 501 N),
PO BOX 365
Schaefferstown, PA 17088



Store Hours:

Monday-Friday: 8:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM, Sunday: Closed

Upcoming Hours Changes:

  • Closed on Thanksgiving Day - Thursday, November 23
  • 7 A.M. to 9 P.M. - Black Friday - Friday, November 24
  • 8 A.M. to Midnight - Midnight Gladness Sale - Friday, December 22
  • Closed on Christmas Day - Monday, December 25
  • Closed on New Year's Day - Monday, January 1, 2024


Welcome to Good’s Store in Schaefferstown, PA!  Our location is found along Stiegel Pike (Route 501) at the edge of the small town of Schaefferstown—rich in history and known for its German heritage. Located in the same complex as Dutch-Way Market & Restaurant and JOY Bookstore and across the road from Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry, Good’s Store serves the needs of Schaefferstown and surrounding areas.  Tourists have been traveling routes 501 and 419 for decades, and recently 419 was officially named a Scenic Byway of the state of Pennsylvania.  Middle Creek wildlife sanctuary is a ten-minute drive from us, and many visitors stop at our store on their way to “see the birds”. We're also a 12-minute drive from Martin Appliance.

The flat fields surrounding the town of Schaefferstown and nearby Myerstown and Newmanstown areas could aptly be named “The Amish Country of Lebanon County”. Passersby enjoy the sights of our Amish neighbors working the soil with their teams of horses, and enjoy the neatly-kept lawns and flowerbeds of local properties. It isn’t unusual for the hitching posts at Good’s Store to be lined up with horses and buggies. When the weather is pleasant, we expect to see a customer’s miniature horse, and its accompanying little wagon, waiting at the railing. 

Clothing & shoe brands include Clarks Shoes, Wolverine boots, Skechers shoes, Muck Boots, Carolina boots, Carhartt, Dickies, Wrangler, Columbia, Hanes, Fruit of the Loom, and Carters Baby Clothing.

Our top home goods & gift brands include DaySpring Cards, Thompson’s Candle Company, Ball, Rubbermaid, Proctor Silex, Yeti, Coleman, Igloo, KitchenAid mixers & accessories, Bosch Mixers, plus many others. We also stock Melissa & Doug and Ertl toys. In our fabric department, we stock Tropical Breeze Fabric, Coats & Clark yarn & thread, Mettler thread, and Dritz Sewing Supplies.

We stock the supplies you need to keep your home and garden well-maintained, including Benjamin Moore paint and Scotts lawn care products. During the winter, you can load up on wood pellets to heat your home and Lyric wild bird supplies to keep your birdseed well stocked.

Many travelers make Good’s Store one of their stops, shopping alongside of local people who stop in on a regular basis. 

Customers often comment on the small-town feel of our Schaefferstown store, and many of them are on first-name basis with each other and our staff.  We invite you to browse our departments—we have items to meet the needs of the whole family and our staff is pleased to serve you. 


Shop Online


Sharpening: Get all your household tools sharpened.
Pinking Shears
Garden Tools
Push Mower
Regular Mower Blades
Ice Skates
Paper Cutter
FlowBee Hair Cutter

Rentals: Rent the equipment you need from Good's Store.
Tables (8-foot)
Ten Gallon Water Cooler
Clothing Racks
Bissell Machines (Rug shampooing)
Fertilizer Spreader

Services Available from Good's Store.
Clothing Alterations
Dry Cleaning
Laser Engraving
Key Cutting
Glass & Foam Cutting
Boat Launch Permits
Hunting & Fishing Licenses
Watch Battery Replacement
Screen & Window Repair
Helium Balloon Filling
Lock Rekeying
Postage Stamps
UPS Shipping
Gift Registries
Goods Store Canning Department YETI mugs for sale Mens Clothing Department