Free Standard Shipping on Web Orders over $75 (Lower 48 States only)

Toy Store in Lancaster, PA

shelves of toys

The toy department at Good’s Store includes toys that encourage imagination in children and help develop creativity. Our selection of children’s toys include hand-crafted Amish-made wooden toys, trucks, tractors and toy horses. We stock board games, children’s toys from Lego, Play Doh, Tomy Ertl tractors, puzzles, books, crafts and much more.

As might be known to most, Lancaster County is home to a large Amish community and they possess considerable skill in craftsmanship. Amish craftsmanship focuses on durability and functionality and they strive to create only high-quality, sustainable items. The Amish might be most known for their skill in making high-quality furniture, but they are also skilled in creating educational, wooden toys for children. While they carry the same high-quality values in their toys, they focus on education versus entertainment.

For example, we had the opportunity to interview the owner of the local business, Lapp’s Toys and Doll Furniture. They have provided families with quality children’s toys and furniture since the late 1970’s. Their collection of heirloom quality, handcrafted wooden products are built to stand the test of time and are meant to be carried on through many generations. Here, you will find the most basic of designs for toy airplanes, cars, trucks, etc. The reasoning is that it’s better for the child’s brain to make the noises and move the vehicles themselves. These days, it’s hard to escape being entertained by a screen, which could stunt young minds when it comes to creativity and imagination. The simplicity of these toys encourage children to create their own worlds and have limitless enjoyment. Click here to shop locally, handmade toys.

Lapp's Handmade Toys

One of our more popular brands is Melissa & Doug. Their classic wooden toys and detailed pretend play sets encourage imagination in children and can help develop motor skills. The collection called “Let’s Explore” encourages children ages three and older to connect with the natural world through imaginative play and helps them discover the joy of outdoor activities that instill curiosity and confidence. Some examples from this collection are the Let’s Explore Campfire S’mores Play Set, Let’s Explore Hiking Play Set, Let’s Explore Fishing Play Set, and more. Along with the Let’s Explore Collection, our Melissa & Doug selection includes various play food sets, wooden puzzles, peg puzzles, many make-believe play sets, educational toys, and so much more.

We also carry toys from brands such as Lego, Breyer Horses, Fisher Price, Schylling, and Toysmith. We carry animal figurines from Safari LTD, and hot wheels from Mattel.

For car lovers of all ages we offer a fascinating collection of model car kits that feature classic and modern cars and trucks from the brands AMT and Moebius Models. Pick out your favorite car along with all the accessories you will need: cement glue, paint, brushes, etc.

We also stock a wide variety of puzzles. Putting puzzles together is a great hobby for all ages. We carry famous puzzle brands like Cobble Hill Puzzles, Suns Outs, Springbok, MasterPieces, and Ravensburger Puzzles – finely crafted puzzles that are a pleasure to put together. Our puzzle department carries puzzles for both children and grown-ups. We also carry accessories for your puzzles such as the Puzzle Stow & Go Mat from Ravensburger, for when you’re short on space, and allows you to safely transport and store your puzzle, the Sort & Save Puzzle Piece Tray from Masterpieces, and the Matte Finish Puzzle Glue from Cobble Hill, for those who wish to save their newly put together work of art and hang on the wall for display.

Good’s Store stocks a wide variety of dolls and accessories, and play sets for hours of fun, nurturing play. We also carry all kinds of plush toys varying in sizes and different animals. We sell plush animals and dolls from Ganz. From Ty, we stock beanie babies, squish-a-boos, keychains, and more. Living Nature offers a wide range of stuffed animals, which are perfect for snuggling. We also carry Warmies. Warmies are stuffed animals of varying sizes that are weighted with grains that are gently scented with lavender, which provides a naturally sweet and calming aroma. These can be a great comfort for children at bed time or when they aren’t feeling well.

Good’s Store also has a collection of crafts for every one of all ages. Some of our children’s crafts include paint by numbers, latch hook kits, Klutz kits, Perler beads. From Harrisville Designs Inc., we carry looms, crochet kits, needlepoint kits which are perfect for beginners.

You’ll also find an extensive assortment of books for children at Good’s Store: bibles, board books, poke-a-dot books, sticker and coloring books from Dover Publications, baby books, classics such as Curious George, Billy and Blaze, Clifford, and more. We also sell activity books from Carson Dellosa Education, Scholastic, School Zone Publishing Company, and Bible activity books from Tyndale House.

If you’re looking for something for the whole family to enjoy, check out Good Store’s board and card game collection. We sell a broad range of games. One popular game is Dutch Blitz, which was developed in 1937 in Pennsylvania by Werner Ernst George Muller who was a German immigrant. The game is fast paced, interactive and so high energy that there is even a jumbo size, which is perfect to play on teams for camps, schools and youth groups. We sell popular games such as Settlers of Catan, Ticket to Ride, along with expansion packs, and several versions of Monopoly as well as classics such as Sorry, Yahtzee, Candyland, Uncle Wiggly, and so many more.

board games

When the weather is nice, spending time outdoors is a must! We carry a large variety of yard games and game balls to keep you active. Spikeball is a fun and fast-paced game that is a cross between volleyball and foursquare. We sell both a Spikeball Standard Set as well as a Pro Spikeball Set. We also offer a few accessories such as a glow in the dark spikeball, and a SpikeBrite attachment for your net. From Franklin Sports we offer yard games such as spyderball, horseshoes, cornhole, and pickleball, just to name a few. We have Molten volleyballs – the official volleyball of the men’s NCAA Championships, as well as a couple options from Tachikara and Franklin Sports. We carry a good selection of baseball equipment such as fielding and batting gloves, bat tape, baseballs, etc. from Franklin Sports. We have footballs, soccer balls, dodgeballs, tennis balls, basketballs, badminton, bocce ball sets and much more. We sell brass quoits sets from Fisher’s Harness Shop, a local company to us. Disc golf is a fun way to spend time outdoors and we carry a wide variety of discs from Innova Disc Golf, as well as a few disc sets and targets from Franklin Sports. Some unique lawn games you will find at Good’s Store include a handcrafted wooden cornhole game made by Valley Road Woodworks and a croquet set handcrafted by Groffdale. Both of these items are Amish-made, have “heirloom quality” and are local businesses here in Lancaster County.

Outdoor Toys

Puzzles and games are a great way to fellowship with friends and family and when you shop the toy department at Good’s Store, you’ll be sure to find something that every one of all ages will enjoy.

Some of our Bestsellers:



Reviews of toys

Some more of our products:Assorted Toys